Turkish Sociologist Declares Children With Autism Born Atheists


istockphoto.com/imaginegolf

Recently, Turkish sociologist Fehmi Kaya declared in numerous Turkish media outlets that children with autism are “atheists due to a lack of a section for faith in their brains.” He elaborated by saying, “That is why they don’t know how to pray, how to believe in God. It is necessary to create awareness [or religion] in these children through methods of therapy.” Digging the hole even deeper he declared, “Research says atheism and autistic children are linked. Researchers in the USA and Canada say that atheism is a different form of autism.”  His organization plans to hold sessions to help autistic children embrace religion beginning this June. 

Frighteningly, this man is the head of the Health and Education Associations for Autistic Children in his native land. When I tried the links to articles about his statements, they were all broken. Turns out, after a firestorm of anger he apologized to autism families, all the while never backing off of his initial premise: “The message I wished to give was not about autism and atheism, but to highlight that these children cannot communicate, cannot form empathy, live in their own worlds and are isolated.  I meant that we should take them out of their isolation with proper therapy methods”. 

It’s tiresome to hear someone, especially someone with power and influence in the Turkish autism community, declare children with autism constitutionally incapable of empathy, especially when there is widespread acknowledgement that autism spectrum individuals can actually feel other people’s feelings too intensely to cope. And unable to communicate? Certainly, communication skills exist on a very broad spectrum. Is it offensive to give children with autism intensive therapy to sensitize them to religion?

Let it be said that Kaya isn’t making up his ideas out of whole cloth.  There is some credence to the idea that the concrete thinking of autism and the propensity of individuals with autism to navigate their world through logical reasoning lends itself to atheist thought. If something can’t be proven, logically it does not exist.  In 2011, a study by University of Boston did suggest that those with high functioning autism were ‘more likely’ to be atheists. 

Yet atheists are displeased with Kaya as well.  According to Carlos Diaz, president of the Atheist Alliance International, “There are scientifically valid methods for treating children with autism, but these have nothing to do with religion. It would be best for the child if treatment focuses on what actually works instead of a highly spurious goal of creating belief.” 

My major problem with Kaya is the rigidity of his declarations. In my own microcosm, one of my twin sons with autism is a spiritual quester, and the other an avowed atheist. In reflecting upon what has worked for my one son in his forays into religion, I suggest that more creativity and flexibility is required on the part of churches in order to reach members with autism.  My son Jackie attempted a formal worship service at a local church, but the hard-surfaced pews and the sheer formality quickly sent him into a tailspin. He couldn’t sit still and remain quiet and people around us glowered and “shh-ed” him. The end result was us bidding a hasty retreat as he starting melting down. 

In contrast, an “Experimental Worship” with stations featuring hands on activities such as lighting candles, weaving a prayer tapestry, asking for a blessing, dropping a stone in a bowl of water to represent letting go of a hurt, etc. was a wild success. As in any environment, accommodation is key. 

Discussions of religions are always fraught with peril. That said, I see my one son’s belief in an orderly universe governed by natural laws as his own sense of God.  And my other child’s spiritual sojourn as a quest for a spiritual community that accepts him as he is.

7 Responses to Turkish Sociologist Declares Children With Autism Born Atheists

  1. Douglas Einer says:

    Does this article imply that ‘being rationally-minded’ is being called a “disorder”-?

    If so, then no wonder this world is in the state that it’s in-!

  2. Susan Moffitt says:

    No, being rationally minded and having autism are subsets that intersect.

  3. Susan says:

    Well thank you.

  4. tryanmax says:

    While I certainly take umbrage at the notion that my autistic child may not be empathetic or able to communicate, I can simultaneously attest that she is well underdeveloped in those areas. As such, I must concurrently take umbrage at the notion that the “broad spectrum” of communication is sufficient for her to navigate successfully through life. My child assuredly needs therapies for communication and social skills; any statement suggestive of the contrary is borne out of ignorance and a misguided display of “tolerance.”

    My offense must continue, it seems, to the idea that because I am tasked with raising an autistic child, I should withhold any/all religion from her despite its importance to me, my family, my heritage and my community. My child’s disability isolates her in enough ways; it is the height of insensitivity to suggest that be increased. I would not tell the atheist parents of an autistic child they are wrong to train that child in the values that are important to them. I would be considered a bigot if I did. Why is the inverse so casually bandied about?

    Furthermore, I must stress that just because one chooses to raise a child in an environment of faith, that in no way hinders that individual from making distinct decisions as an adult. (I am excepting, of course, the extremities of a cult-like upbringing, which is rare.) The number of atheists who were brought up religiously is testament to that. Similar examples abound in regards to politics, career, sexuality, and so on.

    Children are malleable and thus fragile, yes. But it is a cruel intolerance that supposes any manner of instruction bestowed upon a child which one disagrees with is necessarily sinister in nature. Such doctrines of suspicion and prejudice are precisely what should not be taught to future generations. But anything which teaches mutual respect and understanding, whether rooted in faith, reason, or otherwise, does not deserve such disdain.

  5. Susan says:

    By “broad spectrum of communication” I meant that no generalized conclusions can be made about the capacities of individuals on the autism spectrum, since their range of abilities is so broad and varied.

    Of course an atheists’ spokesman is going to be disdainful of religious instruction. No surprise there.

    Thanks for writing.

  6. tryanmax says:

    Thanks for clarifying. I misunderstood that as meaning “all forms of communication are equal” which, obviously, they are not.

  7. Susan says:

    Glad to be on the same page.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

 
 

Terms & Privacy Policy

All information in this site is presented for support and educational purposes only. It is not intended to substitute for medical treatment or visiting a licensed medical physician. Visitors who desire to apply or use any information listed herein are urged to consult with licensed healthcare professionals first. All information is deemed reliable but its accuracy can't be guaranteed.

Read our full TERMS AND CONDITIONS
Read our PRIVACY POLICY

Did You Know?

  • * In 1970, Autism affected 1 out of 10,000 children
  • * Autism now affects 1 out of 88 children
  • * Autism affects 1 in 54 boys
  • * 1.7 million Americans have some form of autism
  • * 4 out of 5 autistic children are boys

RSS Latest Article Entries

  • Foods For Thought: An Insight Into Special Diets February 19, 2014
    Diets: caveman, paleo, “ape,” low carb, low glycemic, zone, ketogenic, specific carbohydrate, GAPS, “grain brain,” “wheat belly”diet — why is there so much interest in these diets? What are they targeting? Is it gut dysbiosis/inflammation or food allergies, or insulin dysregulation, or gluten intolerance, the optimal primate food, or something else? Is there […]
 

Home - Autism Symptoms - Autism Videos - Autism Organizations - Autism Message Boards - Articles - Autism Recipes - Hyperlexia - Fragile X - Tag Cloud - AQ Test - Contact